Behind the question of whether a billing system can help your SaaS business grow is the question of what it means for a SaaS business to grow. This guide tackles both — it creates a model you can use to approach SaaS growth and a 360-degree view of how your billing system fits into it. Read More >
When you transfer money to your friend’s account, ever wondered how it works? You just specify the account number and the routing number. But what actually happens behind the scenes? Here is a step by step breakdown of how a bank transfer via ACH works. We’ll try to steer away from jargon as much as possible.
ACH Transfers are electronic transactions which allow people to pay directly via their bank accounts. It is for banks based in the United States only. The UK equivalent of an ACH payments is SEPA. Gocardless is also slowly emerging as an alternative in the UK. (Chargebee now supports ACH in the US. We’re looking at SEPA & Gocardless next!).
ACH stands for ‘Automated Clearing House’. It is basically a central clearing system. Whoa! Jargon alert.
Here’s the breakdown: Millions of bank transactions happen everyday among different banks. You transfer money from your Bank of America account to your friend’s Silicon Valley Bank account, while she transfers money to an HSBC account. There might be lots more like you making a transaction between these two banks and other banks as well. So how does money move around the banks?
As a kid I always thought that when a bank transfer takes place between two banks (yours and your friend’s), a guy rides his bicycle to your bank, takes $100 from your bag of money, puts on a cap, takes his cycle and drives to the other bank and deposits it in your friend’s bag of money. But it turns out it’s much cooler & slightly complicated than that.
In reality, it’s virtual money which moves around. Say, you transfer money to a Silicon Valley Bank account from your Bank of America account. And someone does an inverse transaction as well. Both the banks have to credit and debit each other’s accounts. An instant credit/debit process for each transaction might sound faster, but has a lot of underlying drawbacks.
The solution? A central clearing system, which keeps stock of how much each bank owes each other and at the end of each day, processes the transactions in batches. This way, the fund transfer happens just once.
Now in any transfer, two main people are involved. The guy who pays and the guy who gets paid. In ACH terms, they are interchangeably called the originator and the receiver. Depending on the type of transaction (credit or debit) where the money goes will vary.
The guy who originates the transaction is the originator and the guy at the receiving end of the transaction is the receiver. So the corresponding banks of the two guys are: Originating Financial Depository Institution (ODFI) and the Receiving Financial Depository Institution (RDFI), a pretty posh name for a bank. The transaction could either be a credit or a debit transaction.
Let’s say Jekyll has to pay a sum of $100 to Hyde (assume they’re two different people) and decides to make an electronic transfer. Here’s what happens:
- The originator (Jekyll) goes to his bank (the ODFI) to initiate a transaction.
- He is asked to submit information like the bank account number, the routing number of the receiver (Hyde). These are called ACH files.
- The ACH files contain a lot of specifications and formats, but they mainly have the receiver’s bank information and amount of the transaction.
- The ODFI then debits Jekyll’s account.
- At the end of the day, the ODFI aggregates all the ACH files and sends them ACH network (The Federal Reserve).
- The Federal Reserve then sorts all the ACH files, and then routes it to the Receiver’s bank - the RDFI.
- The RDFI then processes the ACH files and credits the receiver’s (Hyde) account with 100$.
The above example is that of when Jekyll pays Hyde. If Hyde has to pay Jekyll, the same process happens in reverse. In such cases, if the Hyde has insufficient funds in his account, the RDFI processes a return. The RDFI uploads the return ACH file to the ACH network, along with a reason code for the error. A return may be processed also due to various other reasons like an invalid account number etc.
In the B2B world, if you run a SaaS company, your bank (your gateway’s bank typically) would be the ODFI, while your customer’s bank would be the RDFI. Your customer authorizes you to debit his bank account on his behalf for recurring transactions.
ACH was developed as a digital alternative to paper check clearing systems. What earlier used to be checks and a lot of paperwork, transformed into an ACH file. ACH files are now transmitted via an FTP server that your ODFI provides you with. But earlier, the ACH files were transmitted via floppy diskettes. So a guy (may/may not have worn a cap) did actually travel to the Federal Reserve to deposit the ACH files.
Now that we’re clear with the how part of ACH, let’s take a look at the why part of it.
If you’re running a subscription-based SaaS business in the US, accepting payments via ACH might be a great solution. Here are a few pointers which might help you decide.
According to NACHA - The National Automated Clearing House Association which governs the ACH Network, around 23 billion ACH Payments were made in 2014.
So, if you’re running a subscription-based SaaS business in the US, accepting payments via ACH might be a great solution. Here are a few pointers which might help you decide.
Benefits of ACH for SaaS & other subscription businesses:
1. Checkout Process - Credit Card vs ACH Payments
There is a slight variation in checkout process of any online payment like credit card, as compared to that of payment via ACH.
Generally, for a customer to pay via ACH, there is a double check process in place.
The customer first raises a request to pay via ACH and then, after verifying the customer, ACH as a payment option is enabled for the particular account. Only then, can a customer make a direct debit payment via ACH.
This two-step process makes ACH a more trustworthy option, when compared to a credit card payment where anyone can sign up.
2. Transaction Fees - The economics behind it
For each credit card transaction, a percentage of the money involved is split across the various entities which enabled the payment. A major chunk of this fee is the Interchange fee.
This Interchange fee is set by the credit card networks like Visa, Mastercard, etc. and is typically up to 2% of the total transaction fee.
But in case of a transaction routed via the ACH network, since it directly deals with the banking network, the interchange fee is around 0.5-1 % of the total transaction.
Here’s a quick math with some general percentage rates to make things simpler:
Let’s say you have an enterprise customer who pays you an annual subscription fee of $10,000.
On an average, you would pay 2.5% of the transaction value + $0.30 towards transaction fee. So, for a $10,000 transaction, you will pay (0.025 * 10,000) + 0.30 = $250.30.
The fee for a typical ACH transaction ranges somewhere around 0.75% per transaction which would be $75. And that’s a $175 saved.
P.S. The actual TDR (Transaction Discount Rate) for ACH varies according to the payment gateway used.
3. Reduce Churn - Failed Payments
Failed Payments continue to be one of the main reasons for churn. Credit card payments fail due to various reasons such as expired cards, canceled cards, blocked cards, transactional errors, etc. Sometimes the customer might have sufficient funds in his/her bank account, but could have exceeded the credit limit. In case of a bank transfer via ACH, the bank account number is used along with an authorization, to charge the customer and unlike card transactions, the probability of a bank transfer failing is very low. Bank accounts rarely expire and account numbers rarely change. Also, unlike card transactions, bank transfers fail only for a handful of reasons such as insufficient funds, wrong bank account information, etc.
Also, the two-level verification process for ACH payments ensures that you maintain a touchpoint with customers. This factors in for churn due to unknown reasons.
4. Built for recurring payments
Although the usage of checks has dropped to a great extent, many enterprise companies still use checks to pay every month in order to avoid the huge chunk of processing fees. ACH, a digital form of checks, came into picture to reduce the overhead of managing paper based checks. With ACH, since the transaction processing is recurring and automatic, you wouldn’t have to wait for a paper check to arrive. Also, since customers have authorized you to collect payments on their behalf, the flexibility of it allows you to collect one-time payments as well. No more awkward emails asking customers to pay up.
For further reading:
Subscription Billing Made EasyTry for free
Recent Blog Posts
Scaling your SaaS billing system can be complex. Here's the guide to making sure your subscriptions don't suffer for it. Read More >
How friction improves UX in SaaS, how it helped Chargebee's onboarding and activation flows, and the right way to handle positive, purpose-driven friction. Read More >