Credit Card Trials Vs No Credit Card Trials – Which way to go?

| |

Reading time ~ 3 minutes.

Free Trial

We’ve got an updated and more detailed post on this topic here.

The decision of whether or not to require trial users to share their credit card information during the sign-up process is among the most challenging decisions facing SaaS business owners. Prevailing thought indicates that requiring a credit card number to engage in a free trial will drastically reduce your sign-up rates, though requiring a number will significantly improve the quality of your leads.

Many users who don’t really need the service or simply can’t afford the cost are naturally filtered out by the risk of being billed at the end of the 30 days.  Unfortunately, there are a myriad of pros and cons that make the decision much more complex than it seems at the surface:

Requiring a Credit Card Improves Lead Quality

Research by SaaS Customer Engagement Platform firm Totango indicates that companies who require a credit card at the time of sign-up experience extremely high conversion rates, with a reported average of 50% trial to paid customer conversions.

Totango - Free Trial to Paid Conversion


Softletter research has indicated that subscription businesses (with industry average of 25% conversions) asking for financial information upfront is an effective way to ensure leads entering your sales funnel are more qualified to become clients.

Easy Sign-Ups Boost Conversion Rates

While companies who require a credit card upfront have an average visit-to-lead conversion rate of 2%, trials with no credit card can increase conversions. Totango reported trials with no credit card had an average visit-to-lead conversion of around 10%, though the lead-to-customer conversion was only around 15%.

Totango - Visitor to Free Trial and conversion


Do Credit Cards Affect Retention?

One of the most fascinating aspects of Totango’s recent research on SaaS conversions in 2012 was the fact that trials with no credit card had a positive correlation to customer retention after 90 days. While credit card trials had an average of 60% retention, no credit card trials were at 80%, meaning the overall end-to-end conversion rate of no credit card trials was 100% higher (1.2% versus 0.6%).

Totango - Retained Info and Conversions end to end


While it’s important to note that the research sample size was limited at 100 vendors, it’s fascinating to consider whether companies who offer no credit card trials experience higher retention over time because they prioritize engaging with their leads.

Free Trials Can Be a Competitive Advantage

Subscription business blogger Lincoln Murphy recommends subscription businesses consider a free trial as a competitive advantage, particularly if their niche includes companies that are large or have a strong reputation.

He asserts that offering a no-risk trial period allows professionals to test products against legacy vendors. Through engagement, free trials provide a distinct possibility of “displacing the legacy player…even for a small, bootstrapped vendor.”

Engagement is Still King

Murphy advocates against a one-size-fits all approach for designing a subscription business process. He writes that engagement is more effective at driving conversions for any SaaS company than a one-size-fits all approach to the trial process: “a really effective [approach]…moves the prospect from where they perceive value to where they realize value.” It’s about engaging with your most engaged prospects to help them realize conversion into a paid customer is a natural choice.

Our Choice is simple.

  1. Do a trial WITHOUT requiring Credit Card.
  2. Use customer engagement and usage tools and focus on trial users who WILL convert.

Author of the post

John Solomon

Marketing Leader / Sales Enabler. Head of India Operations for @Infrascale / @sosonlinebackup.

Hear from a team of curious beings
A team that’s bent on delivering the best stories, lessons, and observations on SaaS, straight into your inbox. Every week.
SaaS Dispatch Team

Subscription Billing Made Easy

Try for free

Recent Blog Posts

Dave Gerhardt's Podcast
The Forgotten Art of Taking The Long Cut with Drift's Dave Gerhardt

The importance of carrying the water, dead role models, and the act of kickfinishing. Read More >

The Buddhist Gift
The Buddhist Gift: Trading Focus for Serendipity, and The Story of Our Logo

Frederick Douglass wrote, we get worked upon by what we work on. Deep focus on something helps shut off distractions. But what if it shuts off the breakthroughs we’ve been seeking? Read More >

David Apple's Podcast
Life and Times of a Customer Success Maverick with Typeform's David Apple

The real purpose of small talk, building a platform for scalable conversations, and the right amount of pluckiness required to apply for FC Barcelona. Read More >

Subscription billing software that lets startups deliver recurring happiness to customers.
How Chargebee Works